Daily Debate Result

Biggest FA Cup Shock?

4 fan votes · Revealed 24 Oct 2026

Fan-voted winner Hereford 2 -1 Newcastle 1972 Think you know ball? Prove it.

Vote breakdown

How the fans voted

4 votes

Hereford 2 -1 Newcastle 1972 3 votes · 75%

Macclesfield 2 -1 Crystal Palace 2026 1 votes · 25%

Shrewsbury 2 -1 Everton 2003 0 votes · 0%

Sutton 2 -1 Coventry City 1989 0 votes · 0%

West Brom 2 - 4 Woking 1991 0 votes · 0%